Not every listing calls for the same negotiating approach. How long a property has sat on the market is one of the clearest signals of how much room you have to negotiate, and how many rounds of counter-offers to expect:
- 0–30 days listed. Sellers are still confident and the listing has momentum. You can typically offer 0–5% below asking, depending on the property, without causing offence.
- 31–60 days listed. Sellers become more open to a competitive offer. 5–10% below asking may be appropriate here - weigh up the property's condition and how motivated the seller seems to be.
- 61–90+ days listed. A property that's sat this long, especially over the summer months, often means it was overpriced or needs money spent on it. Offers of 10–15% below asking could be appropriate, but judge each case on its own merits.
Home Owners Alliance research backs this up. They found that the market splits almost evenly: 39% of buyers paid full asking price, while another 39% got a discount accepted. Among those who negotiated successfully, most saved up to 5% (20%), fewer managed 5–10% (14%), and a handful pushed past 10% (6%) . Bolder offers, in the 10–15% range, tend to work in exactly the conditions our 61–90+ day bracket describes: a tired listing, a seller in a hurry, or a buyer who can move fast.